You are here

Writing Review Papers

on Oct 10, 2017

“I have no idea how to write my paper reviews" – if this is the reason you are reviewing this page right now, you must be new to preparing reviews. The good news is – the task you are given is not as complex as you think. Moreover, this article is designed specifically for providing you with all the necessary help writing a review and tips required for the successful task completion.

How to Write a Review?

Start out by accomplishing a cumulative overview of the paper you have chosen or have been given together with its contributions. This brief overview of the main contributions of the work shows to you and writers that you understand the paper's main point. Additionally, it will help you formulate the paper's principal conclusions and contributions. Have a go at describing the type of paper, its context alongside with contributions and overall correctness. In case you cannot summarize the text briefly, then it is out of condition, and you may point this fact out in your review.

Determine whether the work holds by the main claims. In case the main contribution is considered as imperfect one, point out whether you think the given imperfection is “destructive”, or whether writers can just easily correct imperfection during the revision when the paper is approved. Often, these defects are removable (for example, contradictive terminology); some other defects may or may not be removable (for instance, a questionable experimental procedure).

Taking into account the fact that it might seem that a defective experimental installation is ”destructive”, ask yourself as one of the reviewers whether conclusions taken from the paper's experiments continue being task-oriented, even if writers and authors have not explained the results properly. When conclusions taken from experiments have a possibility to be rearticulated and still look like essential contributions – or, in case the experiment's imperfection does not have an impact on conclusions, even such defect can be corrected during the revision. From time to time, even experiments have to be redesigned completely since they do not back up any task-oriented conclusions.

More often than not, in the process of writing a review, you can face a great number of unexpected complications and difficulties. Therefore, you may feel a need to get a professional academic writing help. Reviews are not always easy things to do, so do not be afraid to ask for assistance if required.

Talk about positive aspects of a work; it is necessary to try to look for something good, even when dealing with ‘unsatisfactory’ papers. It may turn out to be difficult to determine some positive contributions and aspects, but the majority of papers typically include at least a few good points. You can point out that some observations are interesting enough and that you would like them to be developed further. Such positive comments are not only intended for martial spirit of authors but also direct authors’ future work.

Do not criticize authors – criticize the work instead. When writing, think about the type of review you want to obtain. Do not be personal; instead, be respectful and polite. For instance, when you state “Authors do not take into account some related works”, that is a more personal statement in comparison with this one "The research does not take into account some related works." Never accuse authors and writers of being unethical researchers. As usual, when being a reviewer, you cannot be fully aware of the whole context, so try to reduce your judgment to what you may draw a conclusion from by means of reading the work.

Think about a possible feedback you want to get. Getting reviews for rejected papers is always an indispensable part of the whole process of research, but it is difficult for authors. Therefore, try to make a positive contribution by means of indicating changes and corrections that you would like to see in future.

Struggling with the Assignment Completion?

Deciding to buy online reviews, you can be sure that our company can offer an individual approach to every single client. So, all difficulties you have with the assignment will be examined and the most appropriate solution will be found.